Is Physicians Formula Mineral Wear as Good as Bare Minerals?

Physicians Formula Mineral Wear and Bare Minerals are two types of powdered mineral make-up lines. Physicians Formula is available in drugstores, while Bare Minerals is available through the company or through higher-end department stores. Physicians Formula Mineral Wear costs less than the Bare Minerals line, but is it as good? Both claim to have pure ingredients and be good for the skin. Consider the ingredients, performance and price to determine whether Physicians Formula Mineral Wear is worth trying out.


As far as ingredients go, Physicans Formula is as good as or better than Bare Minerals, simply because Physicians Formula does not use bismuth. Bare Minerals foundation contains titanium dioxide, bismuth oxychloride, zinc, mica and iron oxide. Bismuth oxychloride imparts a pearly glow to the make-up and is also found in pearlized eyeshadows and lipsticks. However, bismuth is a heavy metal and can cause allergic reactions in some people, including rashes and aggravation of acne or rosacea.

Physicians Formula Mineral Wear contains mica, zinc oxide, zinc stearate, boron nitride, lauroyl lysin, retinyl palmitate, tocopheryl acetate, methylparaben and propylparaben. Instead of bismuth, boron nitrate is the ingredient that imparts shine. Parabens may cause sensitivity in some cases. Both use titanium dioxide and zinc oxide as sunscreens. Though it would seem that the shorter the ingredient list, the better, this is not always true. If you have sensitive skin, the bismuth in Bare Minerals may irritate it, so Physicians Formula is worth a try.


Performance is subjective and depends on the individual. Factors like skin oiliness, physical activity and heat all affect how long the make-up lasts. Bare Minerals tends to last longer, due to the buffing action used to apply it; it forces it into the skin more. Physicians Formula Mineral Wear may not last as long if your skin is oily or if you are sweaty. Those with dry skin should adequately hydrate their skin before applying either make-up, as the powders can be drying.


Physicans Formula Mineral Wear costs $10.49 for 0.49 oz. (14 g). You purchase this make-up line at drugstores, which mostly do not offer your money back for opened make-up. If you try Physicians Formula and do not like it or have a reaction, you will have sacrificed the $10.49. Bare Minerals offers the powdered foundation for $25 (0.3 oz). A kit, complete with brushes, mineral veil, concealer powder and bronzer costs about $60. Bare Minerals offers a 60-day money-back guarantee, so if you try it and don’t like it or have an allergic reaction, you may return it. If you purchase Bare Minerals at a department store, ask about their return policy; most stores allow 30 days to return the product with the receipt.
Is Physicians Formula Mineral Wear as Good as Bare Minerals? by